Lessons from the Fat-o-Sphere

Lessons from the Fat-o-sphere, by Kate Harding and Marianne Kirby, arrived today.  Part of me wants to read (not skim) the whole thing and let it marinate in my brain over the weekend and then post a comprehensive, reasoned review.

Like anyone has the patience to do that after all we’ve been anticipating this for months!!!   So here’s my “Hey, have you read ________ yet?  What do you think of ______?”  Off-the-cuff brain spew.   (Do I need to post a spoiler warning?? :)

This book is what it says it is: “Quit dieting and declare a truce with your body”.  It’s focused on self and body acceptance and building a life you like now and not putting it off until you lose 40 or 80 or 160 pounds.   It starts with how diets don’t result in permanent weight loss and health at every size and that health isn’t an obligation, but that’s just the beginning, because there’s a lot more about being a self-accepting fat person in this society.

  • There’s dealing with the medical industry and finding doctors who will do more than weigh you before diagnosing your strep throat or sprained ankle or cancer as “obese”, and will measure your blood pressure properly.
  • There’s dealing with problems, like depression, that you may have been putting off dealing with until you lost the weight – or that you’d figured would be fixed by getting thin.
  • There’s the importance of having friends and partners who like you the way you are and not settling for someone who wants you to lose weight.
  • There’s replacing the time you used to spend obsessing about your weight and food with activities and hobbies that you enjoy – or maybe getting better at something you already do.
  • There’s accepting that if you quit a certain exercise activity 6 months ago, it’s probably because you don’t love it, and that’s okay.
  • There’s realizing that TV and magazines present women who are much thinner and better-dressed than average as “normal” and “average”, which can really skew your thinking.  It’s not just the diet ads you have to be careful of!

“Like yourself now: Be 10 years ahead of your friends.”  – Jean Cocteau

Lessons includes information about why diets don’t work in the long term and how good nutrition and exercise will improve your health regardless of weight, complete with references, but that is not the sole focus of the book.  If you are looking for an in-depth discussion of the research, I’d recommend you start with Health At Every Size by Linda Bacon, PhD.   OTOH, HAES is pretty focused on diet (both in the weight loss sense and the what people eat sense), food politics, and self-esteem.  Both are very valuable, accessible additions to the fat acceptance library and books I’d recommend for people new to the idea of fat acceptance.

Another viewpoint is here.

4 thoughts on “Lessons from the Fat-o-Sphere

  1. It is good to see someone around the fatosphere admit that, for all the happy talk, HAES still does encourage weight loss & hold out the hope that by living ‘healthy’, people will weigh somewhat less. It is the major reason why I groan when fat activists burble on about HAES & why I am not a proponent…to me, it is still basically “diet lite” & it is the main reason why I have no intention of buying Bacon’s book. I am nearly 60 years old & I don’t need Linda Bacon or anyone else telling me how to live in my own body or recommending a diet by some other name.

    I may buy Kate & Marianne’s book, though, it sounds like fun & I do like support things which are fat-positive. I wish them well with the sales & I also hope that perhaps they can reach more people with the idea of accepting & loving their natural bodies.

  2. Pingback: Spotted at the Bellevue Barnes & Noble « Living ~400lbs

  3. Pingback: Things That Make Me Go “Hm” « Living ~400lbs

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s