Ripping off the Yay! Scale

For years, Marilyn Wann has created and sold Yay! scales, used them in anti-diet activism, and written about them online and in her book FAT!SO? : Because You Don’t Have to Apologize for Your Size. Others have mentioned Yay! Scales in books as well, including Health At Every Size.

Now Kellogg’s is using a very similar scale to sell their “Special K Challenge”. According to The New York Times:

In a new commercial, women in Times Square reluctantly agree to get on scales in public, then are pleasantly surprised when, instead of numbers, the scales display words including satisfaction, pizazz, confidence and moxie.

The commercial, part of campaign by the Chicago office of Leo Burnett, part of the Publicis Groupe, will be introduced on Jan. 2, high season for weight-loss companies.

“We’re trying to change the conversation from one that’s always focused about deprivation to one that’s focused on motivation,” said Doug VanDeVelde, senior vice president for cereal marketing at Kellogg.

Let me get this straight.

The entire point of a Yay! Scale is that you get compliments instead of a number.

Because the number isn’t important.

Because so many people in this society measure their worth by their weight.

Because it’s about changing the conversation. 

It’s about yanking away that all-important number and suggesting other things might be more important than weight.

It’s about making people smile instead of feeling judged.

It’s about changing the focus to life instead of weight. It’s about getting a life instead of yet another a diet.

And here’s Kellogg’s acting like they invented a scale that gives compliments, only it’s to encourage dieting.   Maybe no one at Kellogg’s knew about the Yay! Scale, but … you know what the first hit Google gives me on “scale compliments”?  A post about … a Yay! Scale.

Remember when Weight Watchers ads claimed that diets don’t work (because somehow Weight Watchers isn’t a diet)?   It’s co-opting the language of fat acceptance, but twisting it to support dieting.

8 thoughts on “Ripping off the Yay! Scale

  1. Amen. There can’t be anything much worse than ripping off the invention of a passionate fat acceptance activist to promote weight loss. And there is NO WAY that they got the idea on their own or did not know exactly what they were doing. I don’t watch much tv, but what little I do watch is greatly reduced in the month of January, & any time I see a diet commercial, I change the channel.

  2. I saw that commercial when I was home for the holidays, and I was like “Is that a yay scale on TV? OH NO it’s a subverted yay scale! RAGE!!”

  3. Oh, Honey, do I ever need me one of these! I have been fighting with low self esteem all my life. As Ru Paul says, if you can’t love yourself, how the hell you gonna love someone else? And furthermore, if I can’t love myself fat I’ll never be able to love myself at any other size–because size don’t matter!

    • I do mean the original Yay scale, of course, and not the Kellogg’s ripoff. I hate those damn Special K ads. I found myself wondering what the hell a Size Sassy was and why the music that went along with it was so annoying!

    • I generally don’t eat cereal because I’m hungry again in an hour. A banana is more filling. (Not that just eating a banana is the world’s best breakfast, but for me, a banana is better than cold cereal.)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s